Publication Peace and Security Rethinking Multilateralism Middle Power Leadership: Can Europe Awaken the Carney Within? 17.11.2026 Sophie Eisentraut | Munich Security Conference (MSC) According to a Munich Security Conference survey, a relative majority of Canadians believe that middle powers can exert strong and independent influence in international affairs. EU citizens are more skeptical. Sophie Eisentraut compares the survey findings and explores how this skepticism can be overcome. Image: Creator: Jason Franson In the last months, the leaders of Canada and the European Union (EU) have missed no opportunity to emphasize the importance of forging closer ties in order to boost both Canada’s and Europe’s ability to cope in an increasingly volatile geopolitical environment. This was a central message in Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney’s address to the European Parliament in September and of the Canada-EU Summit in Montréal at the end of October. On both occasions, Canada’s Prime Minister and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen demonstrated their desire to take this crucial partnership to new, unprecedented levels, speaking of a “unique alliance” and an “alliance for the future” that might even see Canada becoming the EU’s first associate member. “Alliance for the Future”? Plans for the partnership outlined so far clearly focus on how both parties can help each other build resilience to the drastic geopolitical shifts currently unfolding. For Canadians and Europeans, the most important of these is Washington’s utterly changed foreign policy, which has seen the US administration targeting its old allies with sanctions, occasionally making demands on their territories, and dismantling the very rules and institutions that had long provided its partner to the North and its allies across the Atlantic with a stable global environment. In substantial terms, the debates in Strasbourg and Montréal concentrated on various measures to reduce vulnerabilities, among them defense industrial integration, closer ties on energy security and critical minerals, and advanced cooperation on artificial intelligence and cybersecurity, among many others. But given that the Canada-Europe partnership is the closest countries have come to building an actual alliance of middle powers since Carney pitched that idea in his speech in Davos at the beginning of the year, expectations for the coalition go far beyond joint resilience building. Many observers hope that Canada and European countries will not only help each other build critical capabilities and reduce risky vulnerabilities but that they will jointly try to stabilize the international order itself. Lack of Confidence While political elites in Ottawa, Brussels, and other European capitals may be in favor of greater investment in elements of international order, the societal confidence needed to back up more ambitious forms of cooperation is more evident in Canada than in Europe. At least this is what is suggested by the results of a survey conducted for the Munich Security Conference in July, which covered Canada, France, Germany, Italy, and the United Kingdom, among others. The results show that what Carney claimed in Davos – namely that middle powers are far from helpless – may have resonated with Canadian society. Europeans, however, seem to be much more skeptical. In Canada, a plurality of respondents believes that powers other than the US and China can wield strong and independent influence on global affairs. In France, Germany, Italy, and the UK, those who share this view are in the minority. Pluralities in those countries instead see a world dominated by Washington and Beijing. Canadians are also markedly more upbeat about their own country’s international clout. Some 47% of Canadian respondents are optimistic about their country’s ability to defend its interests in the world. In Germany, barely a fifth of respondents share this view (19%), while an outright majority of respondents (51%) are pessimistic. Optimism is similarly thin on the ground in Italy (20%), France (23%), and the UK (30%). The pattern repeats itself when it comes to bringing that influence to bear on global problems. Whereas half of Canadians (50%) think that their country is likely to play a more active role in tackling global problems such as climate change, health crises, or humanitarian emergencies, across the four European countries surveyed, an average of just 24 percent say the same about their own countries. Image: Creator: MSC/Ipsos Towards Greater Ambition A new partnership between Canada and Europe that can help both parties navigate an increasingly orderless world is clearly to be welcomed. Yet, if their cooperation is to address the more far-reaching goal of stabilizing the international order as such, European societies may need to channel more of the confidence and ambition that Canadians seem to already exhibit. Efforts to deepen people-to-people connections, which form an integral part of the Canada-EU partnership project outlined in Montréal, might help Europeans to awaken the Carney within. Image: Creator: FES / André Bueno Author Sophie Eisentraut is a member of FES’ North South Futures Forum. She is Head of Research & Publications at the Munich Security Conference (MSC). She is one of the editors of the Munich Security Report, the MSC’s annual flagship report that serves as a conversation starter for the Munich Security Conference each February. With publications on the global debate about Western double standards and on cooperation on the provision of global public goods between European states and countries of the Global South, Sophie has sought to strengthen the debate around North-South cooperation in the framework of the MSC. Sophie holds a PhD in political science and a master’s degree in international relations from Freie Universität Berlin. The North South Futures Forum This article was produced in connection with the North South Futures Forum (NSFF). Organized under the leadership of our New York office, the NSFF brings together international decision-makers and experts from the Global North and South to advance progressive multilateralism in an era of geopolitical fragmentation. Its aim is to promote fairer global rules, stronger institutions, and new alliances. The Forum’s next meeting will take place in India in 2027. Learn more